Surprise!

Overview

As Mike goes to great lengths to keep Leigh from uncovering his plans to throw her a surprise birthday party, Eve develops a crush on a substitute teacher at school, unaware that he has feelings for Annie.

Guest Stars

Samantha Bee

Dr. Young

Jake Lacy

Scott

Kevin Carolan

Carnival Guesser

Evan O'Reilly

Singer

Kimiye Corwin

Pedicurist

Tim Intravia

Silver Man

Rajeev Pahuja

Carnival Worker (uncredited)