The Lady or the Tiger

Overview

A female magician performs at City Hall and Mike asks her out. Stuart and Carter purchase a bar. After sleeping together and telling him she's not interested in a long-term relationship, the magician says ""I love you"" to Mike. Stuart wants to make the bar a gay bar. Mike has trouble breaking up with his girlfriend. The bar is closed because it was missing a permit, leaving Stuart and Carter penniless. Mike finally tells his girlfriend how he feels and they break up.

Guest Stars

Noelle Beck

Kaari the Magician

Lee Bryant

Linda, Kaari's Mom

Steve Brady

Dad

Sam Fox

Audience Member (uncredited)